Climate Change, Forests and Rural Development in Highland Mexico
*Dr. Graham Woodgate
(Photo: The volcanic cone of the Nevado Toluca rising above the forests below)
Reducing carbon emissions from deforestation and forest degradation (REDD+) is a key plank of global climate change mitigation strategies. Opinion is divided on the efficacy and ethics of REDD+ mechanisms, in no small part due to the complexity of the two-way relationship between forests and climate and the structural characteristics of North-South relations.
A recent trip to highland Mexico provided some interesting insights into these issues and underlined the importance of ensuring that the local needs and capacities of rural communities are not forgotten in our attempts to address the most ubiquitous threat to human security in the 21st century.
Earlier this year, the Institute for Agricultural and Rural Sciences at the Autonomous University of the State of Mexico (ICAR, UAEM) invited me to facilitate a research workshop on climate change and natural resource policy and management. After the workshop, I accompanied colleagues from ICAR into the field to observe and discuss ongoing research. My first trip was to the municipality of San Felipe del Progreso, to visit a project for the in-situ conservation of maize genetic diversity.
Maize was first domesticated in Mexico, which is the world centre of maize genetic diversity, representing a vital resource for developing new varieties that can help to ensure future food security in the context of climate change. Together with the farmers of San Felipe, who cultivate an impressive 30 plus varieties of maize in their small upland fields, the researchers at ICAR are helping to preserve this genetic heritage against a backdrop of agricultural modernisation that seeks homogeneity rather than diversity.
(Photo: Researcher and farmer with local maize varieties)
I carried out PhD field research in San Felipe in the late 1980s and was startled by the changes that have occurred since then. In 1992 revisions to Article 27 of the Mexican Constitution brought an end to 60 years of state-led agrarian reform and provided for the division of community lands (ejidos) into individual private holdings in order to facilitate market-led agrarian restructuring.
The extent to which this has occurred is debated, but in the Valley of Toluca it is quite clear that significant areas of agricultural land, rather than shifting from subsistence to commercial agriculture, have been turned over to urban uses, with housing developments springing up along every newly metalled road.
As the terms of trade have declined for basic crops, it has become increasingly difficult to subsist in the countryside. Those that remain may receive remittances from family members that have migrated, but on a daily basis they depend on what value they can extract from available natural resources.
Some farmers have shifted into more lucrative livestock production. While Galicia and Garcia-Romero (2007) have suggested that this may reduce the pressure for deforestation, my recent visit suggested that other factors, including phenomena associated with climate change and rural poverty, are also influencing forest health and land cover.
The second field trip of my recent visit took me to the Nevado Toluca, Mexico’s fourth highest peak, which was designated a national park in the 1930s in order to protect the volcano and its extensive pine-oak forests. As with maize, Mexico is the global centre of biodiversity for both pine and oak, making conservation a vital international, as well as local, issue.
ICAR’s research is generating important information in terms of the struggle to halt deforestation and forest degradation. Back in the 1980s the Nevado’s forests reached the limits of tree growth at around 3,800 m. One of ICAR’s most significant findings is the occurrence of small groups of young trees growing at significantly higher altitudes. This suggests that as global warming progresses, the tree line is advancing and the forests are expanding up-slope.
Unfortunately limited forest expansion at higher altitudes is more than offset by forest degradation further down slope. Unlike many national parks, the designation of the Nevado Toluca did not involve the expropriation of land. Agrarian reform communities and private land owners alike were allowed to retain ownership, although restrictions were placed on land use and support was provided for tree planting. Despite protected area status, however, forest cover within the park has dwindled from over 50 to less than 20 thousand hectares, while the density of tree cover has reduced, leading much of the remaining forest to be classified as ‘fragmented’.
The struggle for survival in the countryside leads people to engage in illegal logging, with individual trees fetching US$ 100 and more. The clandestine nature of this activity means, that in order to avoid detection, people come into the forest for short periods, cutting just a few of the larger trees, often with no more than hand tools. Along with a warming climate, illegal logging might also contribute to the increasing numbers of insect pests, such as pine bark beetles, which are attracted by chemicals released when trees are injured.
In particular, Mexico is seeing a significant loss of forest cover due to infestation by Dentroctonus spp. – the ‘tree killers’. These beetles bore in through the bark to excavate egg galleries. An early sign of infestation are the resin tubes that form on the bark at the entrance to the beetle’s tunnels. When the eggs hatch the larvae begin to devour the living tissue, destroying the trees’ ability to transport water and nutrients, ultimately resulting in premature death.
In addition to illegal logging and beetle infestation, the Nevado’s forests are also being degraded by the activities of livestock farmers. At the end of each dry season farmers burn off the dead vegetation beneath the forest canopy in order to encourage earlier and more nutritious grass growth for their sheep and cattle. Although many species of pine growing at high altitude require periodic fires to release seed from cones for the regeneration of the forest, this burning destroys any young seedlings that may have been established during the previous spring and summer.
In concert, illegal logging, beetle infestation and forest fires all add up to a very alarming rate of forest degradation and have almost certainly caused the forests of the Nevado Toluca to shift from being net carbon sinks to net emitters, providing further positive feedback into the climate change equation.
It must also be recognised that illegal logging and forest fires are ultimately a result of poor people’s struggles to make ends meet. Thus, if policies such as the UNFCCC’s REDD+ strategy are to achieve the desired results, close attention must be focused on mechanisms that can provide realistic and reliable alternative incomes for otherwise marginalised rural people.
*Graham Woodgate is Senior Lecturer in Environmental Sociology at the Institute for the Study of the Americas, University of London.
Comments are closed.
The Durban Platform: Implications and Scenarios in Latin America (2012)
This report analyzes submissions made by Latin American countries to the Ad Hoc Working Group on the Durban Platform for …
Sustainable Development 20 years on from the Earth Summit: Progress, gaps and strategic, guidelines for Latin America and the Caribbean (2012)
This report by ECLAC published in March 2012 prior to the Rio+20 Conference offers an analysis of progress made and …
Capturing the Riches of Bolivia: Utilizing Historical and Contemporary Experience in Bolivian Mining to Inform Future Resource Policy (2012)
Centuries of foreign extraction of Bolivian natural resource wealth have occurred at the expense of environmental protection and overall development …
Indigenous Knowledge and Climate Change Adaptation in the Peruvian Andes (2012)
Indigenous peoples have extensive knowledge of their local environment and this knowledge can be a valuable tool for climate change …
Shaping the Durban Platform: Latin America and the Caribbean in a future High Ambition Deal (2012)
After the longest session on record, governments at the COP17 in Durban in December 2011 agreed to negotiate by 2015 …
Three Hungry Giants: China, the U.S. and the E.U.’s battle over Latin America’s natural resources, and its implications for climate change and resource scarcity (2012)
This presentation was made on April 6, 2012, by Brown University Research Fellow Guy Edwards and Professor Timmons Roberts at …
Poles Apart – The international reporting of climate change scepticism (2011)
Poles Apart is a wide-ranging comparative study on the prevalence of climate scepticism in the media around the world. It …
Dangerous Climate Change in Brazil: A Brazil-UK Analysis of Climate Change and Deforestation Impacts in the Amazon (2011)
This collaborative project between the Centro de Ciência do Sistema Terrestre (CCST) of the Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas Espaciais (INPE), …
Civil-Military Collaboration to Address Adaptation to Climate Change in South America (2011)
This paper, published by the Center for Strategic Leadership (CSL) at the U.S. Army War College (USAWC), was written by …
‘Will cattle ranching continue to drive deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon?’ (Paulo Barreto, 2011)
This is a presentation made by Paulo Barreto, Senior Researcher at IMAZON, at the April 8th Brown University Conference on …
‘Slow Boil: Colombia’s response to the chronic emergency of climate vulnerability’ (Antonio Hill, 2011)
This is a presentation made by Antonio Hill, Regional Advocacy and Campaigns Adviser for Latin America and the Caribbean for …
‘The Squeezed Middle: Why Latin America Matters in Climate Politics’ (Monica Araya, 2011)
This is a presentation made by Dr. Monica Araya, E3G Senior Associate and adviser to the Ministry of Environment of …
Scoping Study of Climate Change Activities across Latin America and the Caribbean to inform the CDKN Regional Strategy (2010)
This study prepared by Guy Edwards attempts to identify the priority needs of Latin American and Caribbean policy-makers with respect …
Regional implications of the Advisory Group on Climate Finance recommendations: Latin America and Caribbean region (2010)
This report was written by Vivid Economics and funded by the CDKN. It was requested by AGF members to help …
Economics of Climate Change in Latin America and the Caribbean Summary 2010
This document, published by the ECLAC and carried out in collaboration with regional governments, the EU, IDB and various other …
IDB Development Effectiveness Overview 2010
This annual report summarizes the actions taken by the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) to measure and improve the social, economic, …
Climate Change: A Research Agenda for Latin America and the Caribbean (Inter-American Development Bank, 2010)
This research agenda outlines the issues requiring further research in order to create an informed assessment of what strategies and …
Latin America finds a voice on climate change: With what impact? (2010)
This article featured in the North American Congress on Latin America written by Jim Shultz and published in 2010 describes the …
Low Carbon, High Growth: Latin American Responses to Climate Change (2009)
The World Bank’s flagship report on Latin America and the Caribbean explores how the region is exposed to climate change …
Climate Change in Latin America (2009)
The European Commission funded a study which would ascertain the problems related to climate change within Latin America. The study …
Up in smoke? Latin America and the Caribbean: The threat from climate change to the environment and human development (2006)
This publication is an important contribution to establish greater awareness about climate change. It is a call to action not …
- International Climate Negotiations (119)
- video (88)
- Public Climate Change Policies (56)
- Adaptation (35)
- Renewable Energy (32)
- Amazon (28)
- Climate Finance (27)
- Civil Society (26)
- Regional Organisations (22)
- Reading List (21)
- Energy (18)
- Biodiversity (18)
- Cities (14)
- Trade & Commerce (13)
- Natural Disasters (13)
- REDD+ (13)
- Market Mechanisms (12)
- Food Security (12)
- Key Posts (11)
- Economics of Climate Change (10)
- Vulnerability (10)
- Sustainability (9)
- Interviews (7)
- The Science of Climate Change (7)
- Climate Justice & Equity (7)
- Publications (5)
- Indigenous Peoples & Tribes (3)
- Transport (3)
- CDM (2)
- Security (2)
- Mitigation (2)
- Migration (2)
- Loss and damage (1)
- Sustainable Development (1)
- Agriculture (10)
Blogs & Websites
- Observatório do Clima
- Blog de Cambio Climático – Perú
- Hablemos de Cambio Climático – blog de BID
- Cambia.pe – Testimonios sobre Cambio Climático
- Cambio Climático Rural
- Climate Change Agriculture and Food Society
- Climate Progress
- Climate Vulnerability Monitor
- The Democracy Center
- Renewable Energy Latin America
- Notes on ICTs, Climate Change and Development
- World People's Conference on Climate Change and the Rights of Mother Earth
- Natural Resources Defense Council – Amanda Maxwell Blog
- Foro sobre Cambio Climático y Comercio
- BBCMundo.com | América Latina
- Bloggings by boz
- Blog de Cambio climático
- Cambio Climático Chile – Terram
- Círculo Verde
- Clima de Preparación – historias de la adaptación, la experiencia, y las exploraciones
- Climate Science Watch
- Conexão Verde
- Ecosystem Marketplace
- Energías Renovables
- Energía Sur – Centro Latino Americano de Ecología Social
- Fórum Brasileiro de Mudanças Climáticas
- Green Momentum – Cleantech for Latin America
- Gráficos Vitales del Cambio Climático para América Latina y el Caribe
- Mudanças Climáticas
- Observatorio Ambiental
- O Eco
- Programa Local de Adaptación al Cambio Climático
- Real Climate Economics
- Responding to Climate Change (RTCC)
- Sistema de Información Ambiental de Colombia (SIAC)
- AlertNet – Climate Change
- Ushahidi – tools for democratizing information and increasing transparency
- Latin American countries attempt to tackle climate change while pushing economic growth
- Chinese loan for oil refinery clashes with Costa Rica’s climate policies
- Think tanks in Latin America have major role to play on climate change
- A New “Why” for Climate Action
- Platform publishes new policy brief on how to strengthen public policies on agriculture, livestock and forests in Latin America
- Peru and Venezuela compete to host COP20 in 2014
- The Politics of Climate Change in Latin America: Leaders and Laggards
- Integrating Climate Migration into Latin American regional forums
- IDB: LAC must urgently adapt to the dangerous consequences of a changing climate
- A New Latin American Climate Negotiating Group: The Greenest Shoots in the Doha Desert
- Trail-blazing schemes show potential of REDD+ in the Brazilian Amazon - Emily Kirkland: I second that- thanks for the...
- Trail-blazing schemes show potential of REDD+ in the Brazilian Amazon - Guy Edwards: Graham – thanks for your...
- Trail-blazing schemes show potential of REDD+ in the Brazilian Amazon - Graham Woodgate: Dear GuyTwo points for you...
- Ecuador’s Yasuní Initiative shakes up the climate-development agenda - Guy Edwards: Rachel: Thanks for your comments....
- Ecuador’s Yasuní Initiative shakes up the climate-development agenda - rachelincolombia: Hi Guy,Thanks for this much...
- Ecuador’s Yasuní Initiative shakes up the climate-development agenda - Amazonia: It is great to develop...
- Latin America, climate change and the countdown to Copenhagen: Interview 1* - kiramatali shah: . According to the...
- Chávez criticizes lack of transparency in Copenhagen - tiffany: Thanks for the post – you might find this...
- Latin America, climate change and the countdown to Copenhagen: Interview 3* - tax jobs: HiIn this site very super ,...
- Adios Chacaltaya - Mbenzi: I was there 1980, before it officially started to melt. One of the strangest places I have...
Challenges for a Climate Compatible Development: How to strengthen agricultural, livestock and forestry public policies (2013)
This policy brief emerges from a process of analysis of the status and quality of the public policies on climate …
Report on the Status and Quality of Public Policies on Climate Change and Development in Latin America (2012)
This report analyses the present status of public policies on climate change and development in Latin America focusing on the …
Political and Institutional Challenges facing Local Climate Change Policies: The experiences of Buenos Aires, Mexico City and São Paulo (2012)
During the last few years, Buenos Aires, São Paulo and Mexico …
Latin American Platform on Climate Strategy 2010
This document outlines the Strategic Lines of Action of the Latin American Platform on Climate.…
Latin America: Climate Challenges for the Region (2009)
A LAPC presentation made at the COP15 in Copenhagen, 14th December 2009…