Show Me the Money: Securing trust in Cancun contingent on cash
As the Cancun climate talks stagger into the final few hours, the need for the wealthy countries to support actions by developing countries remains a core issue for negotiators. But for Latin American nations, the amount they can expect to receive is uncertain.
Ever since the very first U.N. conference on the environment back in Stockholm in 1972, developing countries have feared that aid funds they desperately required for basic needs like education, health, and infrastructure might be diverted to green issues, and that they’d have to slow their much-needed economic growth.
Way back then, Brazil’s negotiator tartly remarked that it was a “happy coincidence” that those countries who created the problem of global environmental damage were also the ones with the resources to clean it up, including by paying to help developing countries reduce their pollutants.
Attempting to reassure them, at every major environmental conference since Stockholm there have been promises of a new funding that would not take away from development assistance. The 1992 Rio Earth Summit conference called it the “Earth Increment,” and it summed to $5 billion US in 1992 dollars. Our research for a book called Greening Aid? showed that only 7 percent of Rio pledges in the Agenda 21 document were ever met.
In 2002 climate negotiations set up no less than three climate funds, but they never had much money in them: expert Benito Mueller of the Oxford Institute for Energy Studies ironically calls them the “placebo funds” since they look like a cure but have no real medicine in them.
Copenhagen’s messy finish last year delivered the biggest promise ever: US $30 billion “Fast Start Finance” over 2010-2012, scaling up to US$100 billion a year by 2020. This is a whole new level of funding flows, and could come to equal all current foreign assistance, which sums at about $140 billion a year (see AidData.org). All of the Copenhagen Accord pledge was supposed to be “new and additional” funding, again, a promising sounding vow.
You wouldn’t think that would be so complicated, but a major flashpoint this year in Cancun is whether developed countries are already merely “recycling” or “relabeling” aid, by calling old projects done for other reasons “climate finance,” in order to meet the promises their leaders made at Copenhagen last year.
A series of reports are showing that the practice is in fact widespread, and there are other issues, such as the fact that no baseline was ever agreed above which spending could be considered “additional,” and whether loans count the same as grants. Worse, it was never defined how much of the pledge can be met with private investments and carbon trading instead of public funds.
The “High Level Panel” studied possible new “innovative” sources of funding like a tiny tax on international currency transactions, or a levy on international airline travel. While some Parties reject some of the options, instituting them are about the only way we can be assured that the funds are truly “new.”
All these quandaries arise when debating the raising of the funds. Governing the funds is part two, but a third and pivotal question for Latin America is who gets priority access to climate funds. As it stands, it does not look good for the region.
The original UNFCCC and Kyoto Protocol texts say that such funds should go first to the “most vulnerable countries.” These countries fall in three categories in the treaties: small island states, least developed countries, and Africa, which contains most of the poorest nations in the world and severe vulnerability to drought and flooding.
In Latin America, only Haiti is among the least developed countries, and the Caribbean islands classify as Small Island States under the agreements, but many are above a likely income threshold to which funds may be earmarked.
Under some current proposals, everyone not in this “most vulnerable” list of countries will have to fight over just 40 percent of the climate finance pie promised at Copenhagen. Some of the funds are entirely earmarked for the least developed countries, which are also the furthest ahead in pulling together planning documents called National Adaptation Programmes of Action. Funding agencies and the U.N. are using these NAPAs to prioritize early funding under the Copenhagen promises.
A sign of Latin America’s desperation on getting a piece of the climate finance pie came this week with a failed gambit by a group of countries including Colombia, Bolivia and Guatemala to create a new category of nations, “Highly Vulnerable Countries.” At the CEPAL event on Wednesday, Guatemala’s representative declared his nation among the ten most vulnerable in the world. The problem is that there is no agreement on how to classify countries on their level of vulnerability—the number of scientifically justifiable indicators is nearly infinite.
At Cochabamba, Bolivia, the People’s Conference declared that distinguishing countries by level of vulnerability should not be done, since it is divisive among the poor nations of the world. This is true—all nations include particularly vulnerable populations and the system should not be based on an either-or classification of being vulnerable or not.
The current list of most vulnerable countries has some fairly arbitrary classifications that should be revised. But it is going to be very difficult to agree on one set of indicators and data to compile a UN Vulnerability Index. This is a crucial but politically thorny endeavor.
The real problem for the whole of Latin America is that this train left the station years ago. It seems somewhat specious to object to classification systems years after they were agreed, and only after the funds begin to flow.
Comments are closed.
The Durban Platform: Implications and Scenarios in Latin America (2012)
This report analyzes submissions made by Latin American countries to the Ad Hoc Working Group on the Durban Platform for …
Sustainable Development 20 years on from the Earth Summit: Progress, gaps and strategic, guidelines for Latin America and the Caribbean (2012)
This report by ECLAC published in March 2012 prior to the Rio+20 Conference offers an analysis of progress made and …
Capturing the Riches of Bolivia: Utilizing Historical and Contemporary Experience in Bolivian Mining to Inform Future Resource Policy (2012)
Centuries of foreign extraction of Bolivian natural resource wealth have occurred at the expense of environmental protection and overall development …
Indigenous Knowledge and Climate Change Adaptation in the Peruvian Andes (2012)
Indigenous peoples have extensive knowledge of their local environment and this knowledge can be a valuable tool for climate change …
Shaping the Durban Platform: Latin America and the Caribbean in a future High Ambition Deal (2012)
After the longest session on record, governments at the COP17 in Durban in December 2011 agreed to negotiate by 2015 …
Three Hungry Giants: China, the U.S. and the E.U.’s battle over Latin America’s natural resources, and its implications for climate change and resource scarcity (2012)
This presentation was made on April 6, 2012, by Brown University Research Fellow Guy Edwards and Professor Timmons Roberts at …
Poles Apart – The international reporting of climate change scepticism (2011)
Poles Apart is a wide-ranging comparative study on the prevalence of climate scepticism in the media around the world. It …
Dangerous Climate Change in Brazil: A Brazil-UK Analysis of Climate Change and Deforestation Impacts in the Amazon (2011)
This collaborative project between the Centro de Ciência do Sistema Terrestre (CCST) of the Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas Espaciais (INPE), …
Civil-Military Collaboration to Address Adaptation to Climate Change in South America (2011)
This paper, published by the Center for Strategic Leadership (CSL) at the U.S. Army War College (USAWC), was written by …
‘Will cattle ranching continue to drive deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon?’ (Paulo Barreto, 2011)
This is a presentation made by Paulo Barreto, Senior Researcher at IMAZON, at the April 8th Brown University Conference on …
‘Slow Boil: Colombia’s response to the chronic emergency of climate vulnerability’ (Antonio Hill, 2011)
This is a presentation made by Antonio Hill, Regional Advocacy and Campaigns Adviser for Latin America and the Caribbean for …
‘The Squeezed Middle: Why Latin America Matters in Climate Politics’ (Monica Araya, 2011)
This is a presentation made by Dr. Monica Araya, E3G Senior Associate and adviser to the Ministry of Environment of …
Scoping Study of Climate Change Activities across Latin America and the Caribbean to inform the CDKN Regional Strategy (2010)
This study prepared by Guy Edwards attempts to identify the priority needs of Latin American and Caribbean policy-makers with respect …
Regional implications of the Advisory Group on Climate Finance recommendations: Latin America and Caribbean region (2010)
This report was written by Vivid Economics and funded by the CDKN. It was requested by AGF members to help …
Economics of Climate Change in Latin America and the Caribbean Summary 2010
This document, published by the ECLAC and carried out in collaboration with regional governments, the EU, IDB and various other …
IDB Development Effectiveness Overview 2010
This annual report summarizes the actions taken by the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) to measure and improve the social, economic, …
Climate Change: A Research Agenda for Latin America and the Caribbean (Inter-American Development Bank, 2010)
This research agenda outlines the issues requiring further research in order to create an informed assessment of what strategies and …
Latin America finds a voice on climate change: With what impact? (2010)
This article featured in the North American Congress on Latin America written by Jim Shultz and published in 2010 describes the …
Low Carbon, High Growth: Latin American Responses to Climate Change (2009)
The World Bank’s flagship report on Latin America and the Caribbean explores how the region is exposed to climate change …
Climate Change in Latin America (2009)
The European Commission funded a study which would ascertain the problems related to climate change within Latin America. The study …
Up in smoke? Latin America and the Caribbean: The threat from climate change to the environment and human development (2006)
This publication is an important contribution to establish greater awareness about climate change. It is a call to action not …
- International Climate Negotiations (118)
- video (88)
- Public Climate Change Policies (56)
- Adaptation (35)
- Renewable Energy (32)
- Amazon (28)
- Climate Finance (27)
- Civil Society (26)
- Regional Organisations (22)
- Reading List (21)
- Energy (18)
- Biodiversity (18)
- Cities (14)
- Trade & Commerce (13)
- Natural Disasters (13)
- REDD+ (13)
- Market Mechanisms (12)
- Food Security (12)
- Key Posts (11)
- Economics of Climate Change (10)
- Vulnerability (10)
- Sustainability (8)
- Interviews (7)
- The Science of Climate Change (7)
- Climate Justice & Equity (7)
- Publications (5)
- Indigenous Peoples & Tribes (3)
- Transport (3)
- CDM (2)
- Security (2)
- Mitigation (2)
- Migration (2)
- Loss and damage (1)
- Agriculture (10)
Blogs & Websites
- Observatório do Clima
- Blog de Cambio Climático – Perú
- Hablemos de Cambio Climático – blog de BID
- Cambia.pe – Testimonios sobre Cambio Climático
- Cambio Climático Rural
- Climate Change Agriculture and Food Society
- Climate Progress
- Climate Vulnerability Monitor
- The Democracy Center
- Renewable Energy Latin America
- Notes on ICTs, Climate Change and Development
- World People's Conference on Climate Change and the Rights of Mother Earth
- Natural Resources Defense Council – Amanda Maxwell Blog
- Foro sobre Cambio Climático y Comercio
- BBCMundo.com | América Latina
- Bloggings by boz
- Blog de Cambio climático
- Cambio Climático Chile – Terram
- Círculo Verde
- Clima de Preparación – historias de la adaptación, la experiencia, y las exploraciones
- Climate Science Watch
- Conexão Verde
- Ecosystem Marketplace
- Energías Renovables
- Energía Sur – Centro Latino Americano de Ecología Social
- Fórum Brasileiro de Mudanças Climáticas
- Green Momentum – Cleantech for Latin America
- Gráficos Vitales del Cambio Climático para América Latina y el Caribe
- Mudanças Climáticas
- Observatorio Ambiental
- O Eco
- Programa Local de Adaptación al Cambio Climático
- Real Climate Economics
- Responding to Climate Change (RTCC)
- Sistema de Información Ambiental de Colombia (SIAC)
- AlertNet – Climate Change
- Ushahidi – tools for democratizing information and increasing transparency
- Latin American countries attempt to tackle climate change while pushing economic growth
- Chinese loan for oil refinery clashes with Costa Rica’s climate policies
- Think tanks in Latin America have major role to play on climate change
- A New “Why” for Climate Action
- Platform publishes new policy brief on how to strengthen public policies on agriculture, livestock and forests in Latin America
- Peru and Venezuela compete to host COP20 in 2014
- The Politics of Climate Change in Latin America: Leaders and Laggards
- Integrating Climate Migration into Latin American regional forums
- IDB: LAC must urgently adapt to the dangerous consequences of a changing climate
- A New Latin American Climate Negotiating Group: The Greenest Shoots in the Doha Desert
- Trail-blazing schemes show potential of REDD+ in the Brazilian Amazon - Emily Kirkland: I second that- thanks for the...
- Trail-blazing schemes show potential of REDD+ in the Brazilian Amazon - Guy Edwards: Graham – thanks for your...
- Trail-blazing schemes show potential of REDD+ in the Brazilian Amazon - Graham Woodgate: Dear GuyTwo points for you...
- Ecuador’s Yasuní Initiative shakes up the climate-development agenda - Guy Edwards: Rachel: Thanks for your comments....
- Ecuador’s Yasuní Initiative shakes up the climate-development agenda - rachelincolombia: Hi Guy,Thanks for this much...
- Ecuador’s Yasuní Initiative shakes up the climate-development agenda - Amazonia: It is great to develop...
- Latin America, climate change and the countdown to Copenhagen: Interview 1* - kiramatali shah: . According to the...
- Chávez criticizes lack of transparency in Copenhagen - tiffany: Thanks for the post – you might find this...
- Latin America, climate change and the countdown to Copenhagen: Interview 3* - tax jobs: HiIn this site very super ,...
- Adios Chacaltaya - Mbenzi: I was there 1980, before it officially started to melt. One of the strangest places I have...
Challenges for a Climate Compatible Development: How to strengthen agricultural, livestock and forestry public policies (2013)
This policy brief emerges from a process of analysis of the status and quality of the public policies on climate …
Report on the Status and Quality of Public Policies on Climate Change and Development in Latin America (2012)
This report analyses the present status of public policies on climate change and development in Latin America focusing on the …
Political and Institutional Challenges facing Local Climate Change Policies: The experiences of Buenos Aires, Mexico City and São Paulo (2012)
During the last few years, Buenos Aires, São Paulo and Mexico …
Latin American Platform on Climate Strategy 2010
This document outlines the Strategic Lines of Action of the Latin American Platform on Climate.…
Latin America: Climate Challenges for the Region (2009)
A LAPC presentation made at the COP15 in Copenhagen, 14th December 2009…